If Mulla is made irrelevant in pukhtoon society....

[nawazgul]

Gulono what do you think if we totaly irrelate and ignore the role of mulla in coming time in our sociology,then dont you think social development will occur with high speed...and if we re-socialize our society in religiouns affair and kickaway the monopoly of mullas and so called aalims on Islam and Quran then can we observe a more caring pukhtoons society..
i just initiated this thread to know your mind reflection about mullas negative role in our society...next dont you think that why we are so confused about simple and clear Islam?is it not just because of blend of pukhtoon culture and mulla made islam in complete form of assimilation....mulla does nt care for cultural relativism but only stress that even put your culture under Arabic culture which is neither the msg of Quran nor Prophet....
In my eye Mulla,Khans and extra sticking to traditions made us behind in the race of development...

[dardmand]

Gulono what do you think if we totaly irrelate and ignore the role of mulla in coming time in our sociology,then dont you think social development will occur with high speed...and if we re-socialize our society in religiouns affair and kickaway the monopoly of mullas and so called aalims on Islam and Quran then can we observe a more caring pukhtoons society..
i just initiated this thread to know your mind reflection about mullas negative role in our society...next dont you think that why we are so confused about simple and clear Islam?is it not just because of blend of pukhtoon culture and mulla made islam in complete form of assimilation....mulla does nt care for cultural relativism but only stress that even put your culture under Arabic culture which is neither the msg of Quran nor Prophet....
In my eye Mulla,Khans and extra sticking to traditions made us behind in the race of development...

Another question:
Is it possible to make Mullah irrelevant in religious matter too?

[Singleton]

Don't you think that with so many uneducated, poor Pakhtuns in the Mountains of Northern Pakisan it would be culturally impossible to avoid Islam and it's influence?

It might be more practical to favor having a more educated system of mullahs to overcome the self annointed and uneducated mullahs who use terrorism to gain personally "in the name of religion" which if I were a Muslim (which I am not) I would define as the attempt to decieve the masses while trying to "kidnap" Islam.

[dardmand]

In our traditional society Mullah was called "Qasab Gar" a lower class of professionals. Why not think over this indigenous solution?

[Lakiwal]

If importance of mullah and its monopoly in our society is finished then every thing will come to its proper place and peace and progress will commence. Curruntly Mulha is seed of all evils related to extremism and terrorism.

[nawazgul]

hmmm.Good reflection guloono.......Ya Dardman said well in our society mulla was considered a Qasabgar as Ghani khan said'
' da mula ibadat kasab
,kenastal au paseda
lda halwa pa armanunu,
,tal Allah Allah kawal..

...Mosque reforms iz required for social reformation.Yes this argument has rational that far flung located areas where pukhtoons are illeterate must be accommodated with mulla but as the settelled areas get rid of this evil soon the repurcussion will be observed in these far flung pukhtoon areas.To offer collective pray iz the duty of each and every muslim not to specifiy a single person llike mulla to lead..this iz against the real spirit of ibadaat....There must be circulatory system while offering prayer.Those in community available for mosque must lead in pray with collective rituals.......But here mulla again put his own illogical points that only pious ppl can lead the collective prayers which can not b jugded by any parameter(bear and turban are the indicators of piousness in mulla blind eye).....Compare the mosque of Prophet the great with current mosque system...The out product of Nabi mosque was amazing which still in continous form while the current mosque system has product in the shape of sectariansim like sunni shia,dewbandi,wahabi etc etc.Totally opposite to the Prophet mosque....tag it ,that mosque(due to mulla) iz the biggest propaganda machine which has organized roots in streets,community and everywhere by which if a mulla wants can defile anyone who iz serving against his vested intrest and will...So many great scholars have been victimised by these propaganda machine..Non of the state of the world has such great and highly organzied machine.Like a fire in jungle it can spread propaganda against anyone..It needs only one Juma khutba to defame anyone.a very short time.Even the women inside four wall can not escape from such propaganda....We must hold the SHARfull tongue of mulla gradually by state control..like sarakari mulla..sarkari khutba as we see in SAUDI ARABIA and other so called muslim countries....

let me tell you my short story..

A few days ago when i was in my village, i told my mosque mulla that today i want to speak Juma khutba bcz i am also muslim and know something about Islam,give me space to address the peopl.He strongly opposed and said what will you say. i said you said about half of IMAN that iz ibaadaat etc now i would say about rest half of Iman that is ''Safaai neem imaan day'' ..actually i wanted to tell my village fellow about growing issue of some rubbish(da kali deraanuna) which growing day by day in our village and is a potential threat to local peopl esp children..So i just wanted to educate my illetrate brothers..But mullah and some elder of my community strongly opposed my idea.They all said u have no bear no turban (share ta barabar na ye..lolz) and younger one...Then i left the mosuqe and went out of mosque(cz mind set needs mor time to change)..I Just pointed to mulla that ustaz ji...Deen is composed of two fundamentals one Ibadaat and other Muamilaat,,,that is God rights and Human rights and ISLAM 85% stress on human rights and in muamilaat as God iz Rehman and Raheem,He can forgive his rights but can not human rights.....Kor ke rata baba me same khabare okre we ta kho lewanay shawey ye,,ha ha ..khabar na o che mata baqi halaq lewani hkaredal...:):)

Thhis was just and example to tell you how tough to bring even a minor change in this stagnant society....But it does nt mean that we should stop ,no, struggle will be on on and on and chang and charity begins at home,neighbour,village.So start by yourself,Try to fill out the gap bewteen theory and practice....

Mula larey ka da myanza mamila sta au zama da
da dastaan da lwoage na de da qisa da ishq au saah da...Ghani khan

[Abdali]

Another question:
Is it possible to make Mullah irrelevant in religious matter too?

Yes...The ignorant Mullah needs to be eliminated from our society.

Illiterate Mullah is mainly responsible for keeping the masses obscurantist, fatalistic and backward in heart and mind.

[intkhabpk]

To me it's more about people themselves who don't get themselves educated and put all the responsibilities on Mullahs thus making them more influential. If people start learning more about their religion then the Mullahs would not have to extend their baseless influence.

[GHARIBUL WATAN]

If mullah has to be blamed then status quo left should also be blamed.

[dardmand]

If mullah has to be blamed then status quo left should also be blamed.
What do you mean by status quo left? What criterion you have in mind for blaming them? And what is the need for blaming them?

[GHARIBUL WATAN]

dardmand saib status quo left are those who do nothing for their oppressed people. whenever they are in power they do corruption and compromise on national interest of their Qoum. they are not in favour of Badloon because change will challege their bureaucratic position in 'leftist' parties.